Building Open Science: Freedom and Sovereignty

When using closed source tools, the software used to build the scientific pipeline is part of the methodology. Using software during your research, makes it part of the methodology. By using closed software/pipelines your research can become not reproducible for other labs or even for you in the future. Licenses may change, prices can be increased, or a piece of software can be suddenly unavailable in your country. Moreover, using closed source software, the scientist cannot guarantee that the software solves the problem it proposes to solve. The scientist has no choice but to trust naively. Let's explore a concrete case. Brazilian universities outsourced their cloud to a Big Tech "Unlimited Drive". Universities were dismantled, losing teams and their own servers. By 2021 (enforced from 2022 to 2024), the "Unlimited" storage was replaced by a 100 TB global cap, which is nothing for a single genetics lab. In the Czech Republic, ELIXIR CZ works really well running on a public Galaxy S

Building Open Science: Freedom and Sovereignty

When using closed source tools, the software used to build the scientific pipeline is part of the methodology.
Using software during your research, makes it part of the methodology. By using closed software/pipelines your research can become not reproducible for other labs or even for you in the future.

Licenses may change, prices can be increased, or a piece of software can be suddenly unavailable in your country.
Moreover, using closed source software, the scientist cannot guarantee that the software solves the problem it proposes to solve. The scientist has no choice but to trust naively.

Let's explore a concrete case. Brazilian universities outsourced their cloud to a Big Tech "Unlimited Drive". Universities were dismantled, losing teams and their own servers. By 2021 (enforced from 2022 to 2024), the "Unlimited" storage was replaced by a 100 TB global cap, which is nothing for a single genetics lab.

In the Czech Republic, ELIXIR CZ works really well running on a public Galaxy Server, sustained by Czech Public funding. Laboratories do not need to pay licenses for DNA analysis, and science is made using public infrastructure funds.

Universities and research institutes cannot be beholden to market fluctuations or geopolitical moods.
A lab in Europe, Brazil, Asia or Africa has to have the capacity to continue its own research independently of external factors.

When science depends on closed tools and/or rented cloud infrastructure, relying on private (and most of the time international) supply chains, there are misaligned incentives dictating the agenda.

Brazil maintains FioCruz (since 1900) and Butantan (since 1901). Both are 100% public linked to Brazil's Universal Public Health System.
They study and manufacture vaccines for local diseases, neglected by the private sector and the global North, like chikungunya.
During COVID, CZ discovered it was at the mercy of international supply chains, subject to market fluctuations and instability of foreign governments in public health emergencies.
ÚSOL, the public vaccine institute, was privatized and sold to real estate speculators. The historic research center was demolished and turned into luxury apartments. Fragile promises that the private sector would maintain the research were not kept.
Sovereignty is about the future we want to build for people,
attending to their needs without making a distinction about where they are from or who they are.

Share